good vibes & pizza pies

anything but ordinary

Welcome to Old Scratch Pizza, where we’ve been slinging some pretty awesome pies since 2016. Born from the idea that pizza should be something you enjoy with the whole crew, we created a place where everyone’s welcome. Whether you’re rolling in with the family, meeting up with friends, or just grabbing a quick slice, you’ll find a laid-back atmosphere, high-quality ingredients, and a spacious, communal beer hall setting.

From our fresh, housemade dough to our creative pies and veggies, we’ve stayed true to our roots, focusing on quality and consistency every step of the way. Over the years, we’ve expanded to four locations across Southwestern Ohio—each one a hub for great food, cold beer, and good vibes.

what is midwesternly neapolitan?

At Old Scratch Pizza, we’re all about putting a fresh spin on the classic pie. Picture this: Neapolitan pizza with a hearty dose of Midwest swagger. Unique? Absolutely. Authentic? You bet.

We’ve got mad respect for the Neapolitan roots, but we’re not shy about shaking things up with flavors that'll make any Midwesterner feel right at home. Each pie is a handmade masterpiece, crafted by our expert pizzaiolos who treat pizza-making like the art form it is. And everything’s made fresh, in-house, because you deserve nothing less.

pizzeria meets beer hall

But hold up, Old Scratch Pizza isn’t just about the pizza. It’s a laid-back hangout spot that practically begs you to "grab a beer and stay awhile."Looking for a chill spot that doesn’t skimp on quality? Old Scratch Pizza is your go-to. Come for the killer pizza, stay for the good times.

Pizza oven icon

TRADITIONAL OVENS

All of the ovens are made in a traditional Italian design and baked at a high, flaming heat.

Neapolitan pizza icon

neapolitan-ish PIZZA

We do neapolitan pizza, but aren’t afraid to break the rules. Our premium  pizzas are inspired by the Midwest and Italian tradition alike.

Ohio pizza

OUR COMMUNITY

We want to create the best environments to enjoy our menu with friends and family. We also value giving back to our community.

what to expect

What is neapolitan pizza?
Plus icon
What do you mean by "Midwesternly Neapolitan" pizza?
Plus icon
Should I fold my slice?
Plus icon
What about extra cheese?
Plus icon

general information

Where is Old Scratch Pizza located?
Plus icon
What are your hours of operation?
Plus icon
How can I contact Old Scratch Pizza?
Plus icon
Do you offer gift cards?
Plus icon

menu & ingredients

What types of pizzas do you offer?
Plus icon
Do you offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Plus icon
Can you accommodate food allergies?
Plus icon

ordering & reservations

Can I place an order online or over the phone?
Plus icon
Do you offer delivery?
Plus icon
Do you offer catering?
Plus icon
Can I make a reservation?
Plus icon

dining experience

How do I order if I want to dine-in?
Plus icon
Is there outdoor seating available?
Plus icon
Do you have any private dining rooms or event spaces?
Plus icon
Are you a family-friendly restaurant?
Plus icon
Do you have a kid's menu?
Plus icon
Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Plus icon
Are pets allowed in outdoor seating areas?
Plus icon

loyalty & rewards

Do you have a rewards program for frequent customers?
Plus icon